Security Aspects of Printed Electronics Applications

Gedruckte Elektronik (Printed Electronics (PE)) ist eine neu aufkommende Technologie welche komplementär zu konventioneller Elektronik eingesetzt wird. Dessen einzigartigen Merkmale führten zu einen starken Anstieg von Marktanteilen, welche 2010 \$6 Milliarden betrugen, \$41 Milliarden in 2019 und in 2027 geschätzt \$153 Milliarden. Gedruckte Elektronik kombiniert additive Technologien mit funktionalen Tinten um elektronische Komponenten aus verschiedenen Materialien direkt am Verwendungsort, kosteneffizient und umweltfreundlich herzustellen. Die dabei verwendeten Substrate können flexibel, leicht, transparent, großflächig oder implantierbar sein. Dadurch können mit gedruckter Elektronik (noch) visionäre Anwendungen wie Smart-Packaging, elektronische Einmalprodukte, Smart Labels oder digitale Haut realisiert werden. Um den Fortschritt von gedruckten Elektronik-Technologien voranzutreiben, basierten die meisten Optimierungen hauptsächlich auf der Erhöhung von Produktionsausbeute, Reliabilität und Performance. Jedoch wurde auch die Bedeutung von Sicherheitsaspekten von Hardware-Plattformen in den letzten Jahren immer mehr in den Vordergrund gerückt. Da realisierte Anwendungen in gedruckter Elektronik vitale Funktionalitäten bereitstellen können, die sensible Nutzerdaten beinhalten, wie zum Beispiel in implantierten Geräten und intelligenten Pflastern zur Gesundheitsüberwachung, führen Sicherheitsmängel und fehlendes Produktvertrauen in der Herstellungskette zu teils ernsten und schwerwiegenden Problemen. Des Weiteren, wegen den charakteristischen Merkmalen von gedruckter Elektronik, wie zum Beispiel additive Herstellungsverfahren, hohe Strukturgröße, wenige Schichten und begrenzten Produktionsschritten, ist gedruckte Hardware schon per se anfällig für hardware-basierte Attacken wie Reverse-Engineering, Produktfälschung und Hardware-Trojanern. Darüber hinaus ist die Adoption von Gegenmaßnahmen aus konventionellen Technologien unpassend und ineffizient, da solche zu extremen Mehraufwänden in der kostengünstigen Fertigung von gedruckter Elektronik führen würden. Aus diesem Grund liefert diese Arbeit eine Technologie-spezifische Bewertung von Bedrohungen auf der Hardware-Ebene und dessen Gegenmaßnahmen in der Form von Ressourcen-beschränkten Hardware-Primitiven, um die Produktionskette und Funktionalitäten von gedruckter Elektronik-Anwendungen zu schützen. Der erste Beitrag dieser Dissertation ist ein vorgeschlagener Ansatz um gedruckte Physical Unclonable Functions (pPUF) zu entwerfen, welche Sicherheitsschlüssel bereitstellen um mehrere sicherheitsrelevante Gegenmaßnahmen wie Authentifizierung und Fingerabdrücke zu ermöglichen. Zusätzlich optimieren wir die multi-bit pPUF-Designs um den Flächenbedarf eines 16-bit-Schlüssels-Generators um 31\% zu verringern. Außerdem entwickeln wir ein Analyse-Framework basierend auf Monte Carlo-Simulationen für pPUFs, mit welchem wir Simulationen und Herstellungs-basierte Analysen durchführen können. Unsere Ergebnisse haben gezeigt, dass die pPUFs die notwendigen Eigenschaften besitzen um erfolgreich als Sicherheitsanwendung eingesetzt zu werden, wie Einzigartigkeit der Signatur und ausreichende Robustheit. Der Betrieb der gedruckten pPUFs war möglich bis zu sehr geringen Betriebsspannungen von nur 0.5 V. Im zweiten Beitrag dieser Arbeit stellen wir einen kompakten Entwurf eines gedruckten physikalischen Zufallsgenerator vor (True Random Number Generator (pTRNG)), welcher unvorhersehbare Schlüssel für kryptographische Funktionen und zufälligen "Authentication Challenges" generieren kann. Der pTRNG Entwurf verbessert Prozess-Variationen unter Verwendung von einer Anpassungsmethode von gedruckten Widerständen, ermöglicht durch die individuelle Konfigurierbarkeit von gedruckten Schaltungen, um die generierten Bits nur von Zufallsrauschen abhängig zu machen, und damit ein echtes Zufallsverhalten zu erhalten. Die Simulationsergebnisse legen nahe, dass die gesamten Prozessvariationen des TRNGs um das 110-fache verbessert werden, und der zufallsgenerierte Bitstream der TRNGs die "National Institute of Standards and Technology Statistical Test Suit"-Tests bestanden hat. Auch hier können wir nachweisen, dass die Betriebsspannungen der TRNGs von mehreren Volt zu nur 0.5 V lagen, wie unsere Charakterisierungsergebnisse der hergestellten TRNGs aufgezeigt haben. Der dritte Beitrag dieser Dissertation ist die Beschreibung der einzigartigen Merkmale von Schaltungsentwurf und Herstellung von gedruckter Elektronik, welche sehr verschieden zu konventionellen Technologien ist, und dadurch eine neuartige Reverse-Engineering (RE)-Methode notwendig macht. Hierfür stellen wir eine robuste RE-Methode vor, welche auf Supervised-Learning-Algorithmen für gedruckte Schaltungen basiert, um die Vulnerabilität gegenüber RE-Attacken zu demonstrieren. Die RE-Ergebnisse zeigen, dass die vorgestellte RE-Methode auf zahlreiche gedruckte Schaltungen ohne viel Komplexität oder teure Werkzeuge angewandt werden kann. Der letzte Beitrag dieser Arbeit ist ein vorgeschlagenes Konzept für eine "one-time programmable" gedruckte Look-up Table (pLUT), welche beliebige digitale Funktionen realisieren kann und Gegenmaßnahmen unterstützt wie Camouflaging, Split-Manufacturing und Watermarking um Attacken auf der Hardware-Ebene zu verhindern. Ein Vergleich des vorgeschlagenen pLUT-Konzepts mit existierenden Lösungen hat gezeigt, dass die pLUT weniger Flächen-bedarf, geringere worst-case Verzögerungszeiten und Leistungsverbrauch hat. Um die Konfigurierbarkeit der vorgestellten pLUT zu verifizieren, wurde es simuliert, hergestellt und programmiert mittels Tintenstrahl-gedruckter elektrisch leitfähiger Tinte um erfolgreich Logik-Gatter wie XNOR, XOR und AND zu realisieren. Die Simulation und Charakterisierungsergebnisse haben die erfolgreiche Funktionalität der pLUT bei Betriebsspannungen von nur 1 V belegt

Counterfeit Detection and Prevention in Additive Manufacturing Based on Unique Identification of Optical Fingerprints of Printed Structures

Printed Electronics (PE) based on additive manufacturing has a rapidly growing market. Due to large feature sizes and reduced complexity of PE applications compared to silicon counterparts, they are more prone to counterfeiting. Common solutions to detect counterfeiting insert watermarks or extract unique fingerprints based on (irreproducible) process variations of valid components. Commonly, such fingerprints have been extracted through electrical methods, similar to those of physically unclonable functions (PUFs). Hence, they introduce overhead to the production resulting in additional costs. While such costs may be negligible for application domains targeted by silicon-based technologies, they are detrimental to the ultra-low-cost PE applications. In this paper, we propose an optical unique identification, by extracting fingerprints from the optically visible variations of printed inks in the PE components. The images can be obtained from optical cameras, such as cell phones, thanks to large feature sizes of PE, by trusted parties, such as an end user wanting to verify the authenticity of a particular product. Since this approach does not require any additional circuitry, the fingerprint production cost consists of merely acquisition, processing and saving an image of the circuit components, matching the requirements of ultra-low-cost applications of PE. To further decrease the storage costs for the unique fingerprints, we utilize image downscaling resulting in a compression rate between 83– 188× , while preserving the reliability and uniqueness of the fingerprints. The proposed fingerprint extraction methodology is applied to four datasets and the results show that the optical variation printed inks is suitable to prevent counterfeiting in PE

Image PUF: A Physical Unclonable Function for Printed Electronics based on Optical Variation of Printed Inks

Printed Electronics (PE) has a rapidly growing market, thus, the counterfeiting/overbuilding of PE components is anticipated to grow. The common solution for the counterfeiting is Physical Unclonable Functions (PUFs). In PUFs, a unique fingerprint is extracted from (irreproducible) process variations in the production and used in the authentication of valid components. Many commonly used PUFs are electrical PUFs by leveraging the impact of process variations on electrical properties of devices, circuits and chips. Hence, they add overhead to the production which results in additional costs. While such costs may be negligible for many application domains targeted by silicon-based VLSI technologies, they are detrimental to the ultra-low-cost PE applications. In this paper, we propose an optical PUF (iPUF) extracting a fingerprint from the optically visible variation of printed inks in the PE components. Since iPUF does not require any additional circuitry, the PUF production cost consists of merely acquisition, processing and saving an image of the circuit components, matching the requirements of ultra-low-cost margin applications of PE. To further decrease the storage costs for iPUF, we utilize image downscaling resulting in a compression rate of 484x, while still preserving the reliability and uniqueness of the fingerprints. The proposed fingerprint extraction methodology is applied to four datasets for evaluation. The results show that the process variation of the optical shapes of printed inks is suitable as an optical PUF to prevent counterfeiting in PE

Inkjet Printed True Random Number Generator based on Additive Resistor Tuning

Printed electronics (PE) is a fast growing technology with promising applications in wearables, smart sensors and smart cards since it provides mechanical flexibility, low-cost, on-demand and customizable fabrication. To secure the operation of these applications, True Random Number Generators (TRNGs) are required to generate unpredictable bits for cryptographic functions and padding. However, since the additive fabrication process of PE circuits results in high intrinsic variation due to the random dispersion of the printed inks on the substrate, constructing a printed TRNG is challenging. In this paper, we exploit the additive customizable fabrication feature of inkjet printing to design a TRNG based on electrolyte-gated field effect transistors (EGFETs). The proposed memory-based TRNG circuit can operate at low voltages (≤ 1 V ), it is hence suitable for low-power applications. We also propose a flow which tunes the printed resistors of the TRNG circuit to mitigate the overall process variation of the TRNG so that the generated bits are mostly based on the random noise in the circuit, providing a true random behaviour. The results show that the overall process variation of the TRNGs is mitigated by 110 times, and the simulated TRNGs pass the National Institute of Standards and Technology Statistical Test Suite

JPEG Image Encryption Via TEA Algorithm

Günümüzde görüntü sıkıştırma ve şifreleme yöntemleri hem görüntülerin daha kolay iletilebilmesi hem de güvenliği açısından hayati önem taşımaktadır. Bu sebeple bu çalışmada JPEG standardı ve Tiny Encryption ¸ Sifreleme Algoritması kullanılarak görüntü şifreleme yapılmıştır. Şifreleme, piksellerin frekansına ve taşıdığı bilgi dikkate alınarak yapılmıştır. En çok bilgi taşııyan piksellerin en düşük frekanslı pikseller olması sebebiyle şifreleme bu piksellere uygulanarak çıkış resminde tam şifreleme elde edilmeye çalışılmıştır. Şifreleme algoritması Verilog Donanım Tanımlama Dili kullanılarak Sahada Programlanabilir Kapı Dizisi (FPGA, Field Programmable Gate Array) üzerinde tasarlanmıştır. Sistemin geri kalanı ise MATLAB ortamında gerçeklenmiştir. Çalışmanın sonunda çıkış resimlerine ait bazı ölçüm sonuçları verilmiştir.Recently, image compression and image encryption methods are very crucial in terms of transmission and security of images. Therefore, image compression and encryption were implemented by using JPEG standard and Tiny Encryption Algorithm. In the encryption part, frequency of image pixels took into consideration. Encryption was applied pixels which have lower frequencies so output images of system was encrypted successfully. TEA was implemented on FPGA by using Verilog Hardware Description Language. Other parts of system were implemented on MATLAB. At the end of this paper, some results of encrypted images were given

Reverse Engineering of Printed Electronics Circuits: From Imaging to Netlist Extraction

Printed electronics (PE) circuits have several advantages over silicon counterparts for the applications where mechanical flexibility, extremely low-cost, large area, and custom fabrication are required. The custom (personalized) fabrication is a key feature of this technology, enabling customization per application, even in small quantities due to low-cost printing compared with lithography. However, the personalized and on-demand fabrication, the non-standard circuit design, and the limited number of printing layers with larger geometries compared with traditional silicon chip manufacturing open doors for new and unique reverse engineering (RE) schemes for this technology. In this paper, we present a robust RE methodology based on supervised machine learning, starting from image acquisition all the way to netlist extraction. The results show that the proposed RE methodology can reverse engineer the PE circuits with very limited manual effort and is robust against non-standard circuit design, customized layouts, and high variations resulting from the inherent properties of PE manufacturing processes

A Compact Low-Voltage True Random Number Generator based on Inkjet Printing Technology

Printed electronics (PE) is a fast-growing field with promising applications in wearables, smart sensors, and smart cards, since it provides mechanical flexibility, and low-cost, on-demand, and customizable fabrication. To secure the operation of these applications, true random number generators (TRNGs) are required to generate unpredictable bits for cryptographic functions and padding. However, since the additive fabrication process of the PE circuits results in high intrinsic variations due to the random dispersion of the printed inks on the substrate, constructing a printed TRNG is challenging. In this article, we exploit the additive customizable fabrication feature of inkjet printing to design a TRNG based on electrolyte-gated field-effect transistors (EGFETs). We also propose a printed resistor tuning flow for the TRNG circuit to mitigate the overall process variation of the TRNG so that the generated bits are mostly based on the random noise in the circuit, providing a true random behavior. The simulation results show that the overall process variation of the TRNGs is mitigated by 110 times, and the generated bitstream of the tuned TRNGs passes the National Institute of Standards and Technology - Statistical Test Suite. For the proof of concept, the proposed TRNG circuit was fabricated and tuned. The characterization results of the tuned TRNGs prove that the TRNGs generate random bitstreams at the supply voltage of down to 0.5 V. Hence, the proposed TRNG design is suitable to secure low-power applications in this domain

A Novel Printed-Lookup-Table-Based Programmable Printed Digital Circuit

Advances in printed electronics (PE) enables new applications, particularly in ultra-low-cost domains. However, achieving high-throughput printing processes and manufacturing yield is one of the major challenges in the large-scale integration of PE technology. In this article, we present a programmable printed circuit based on an efficient printed lookup table (pLUT) to address these challenges by combining the advantages of the high-throughput advanced printing and maskless point-of-use final configuration printing. We propose a novel pLUT design which is more efficient in PE realization compared to existing LUT designs. The proposed pLUT design is simulated, fabricated, and programmed as different logic functions with inkjet printed conductive ink to prove that it can realize digital circuit functionality with the use of programmability features. The measurements show that the fabricated LUT design is operable at 1 V

A Printed Camouflaged Cell against Reverse Engineering of Printed Electronics Circuits

Printed electronics (PE) enables disruptive applications in wearables, smart sensors, and healthcare since it provides mechanical flexibility, low cost, and on-demand fabrication. The progress in PE raises trust issues in the supply chain and vulnerability to reverse engineering (RE) attacks. Recently, RE attacks on PE circuits have been successfully performed, pointing out the need for countermeasures against RE, such as camouflaging. In this article, we propose a printed camouflaged logic cell that can be inserted into PE circuits to thwart RE. The proposed cell is based on three components achieved by changing the fabrication process that exploits the additive manufacturing feature of PE. These components are optically look-alike, while their electrical behaviors are different, functioning as a transistor, short, and open. The properties of the proposed cell and standard PE cells are compared in terms of voltage swing, delay, power consumption, and area. Moreover, the proposed camouflaged cell is fabricated and characterized to prove its functionality. Furthermore, numerous camouflaged components are fabricated, and their (in)distinguishability is assessed to validate their optical similarities based on the recent RE attacks on PE. The results show that the proposed cell is a promising candidate to be utilized in camouflaging PE circuits with negligible overhead